4 Best Car Accident Lawyers in Boston (Ranked by Case Results)
Massachusetts had over 116,000 car crashes in 2024. More than 2,000 people suffered serious injuries. Another 339 lost their lives.
Those numbers come from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. Not from a law firm website. Not from a billboard.
Here is another number. Most car accident victims never see a dime beyond their own $8,000 in Personal Injury Protection coverage. Why? Because they hire lawyers who settle too fast. Or they do not hire anyone at all.
The four firms on this list have something in common. Each one has taken a case to court and walked out with a check. Not a settlement. A jury verdict. Or a settlement that happened after the lawsuit was filed, which is a completely different number than a pre suit offer.
We pulled court records. Read news articles. Gathered the actual dollar amounts from verifiable sources. Then ranked these four Boston car accident lawyers by the size of their largest documented win.
Keep reading to see the full list.
Ranking Criteria
Three factors determined the order.
First, the largest single case result each firm has publicly documented. Second, the total number of seven-figure wins. Third, whether the firm takes cases to trial or settles everything.
Insurance companies track this data. They know which Boston car accident lawyers actually file lawsuits and which ones fold. That knowledge directly shapes the settlement offers they make.
Let us show you who came out on top.
1. Michael Kelly Injury Lawyers
Pre-Litigation Attorney Michael Satterwhite handles car accident claims for this firm. His recent results, posted on the firm’s LinkedIn page, show what they can do.
A client got rear-ended by a semi truck driver. Satterwhite secured $700,000.
An Uber passenger suffered injuries when their driver drove recklessly. The firm obtained $180,000.
An 18-wheeler hit someone and drove off. Hit-and-run cases are hard to win. Michael Kelly Injury Lawyers still got $100,000.
A drunk driver speeding down the road struck a pedestrian. The firm won $75,000.
These are not firmwide totals. These are single cases handled by one attorney. The firm’s website also mentions additional settlements at $700,000, $400,000, and $675,000.
Beyond the money, the firm offers something unusual. A 30-day satisfaction guarantee. Most personal injury lawyers make you pay if you leave. These lawyers do not.
Lexinter hosts a dedicated profile for Michael D. Kelly. TrustAnalytica ranked them number one in Boston. USAttorneys lists them as a Premium Member.
Their main office sits at 65A Atlantic Ave. Eleven locations total across Massachusetts, New Hampshire, and Connecticut.
2. Sweeney Merrigan Personal Injury Lawyers
Largest documented case result: $84.1 million
That number is not a typo. Eighty four point one million dollars. But here is the important detail. That money went to Massachusetts cities and towns, not a single client. More than 100 municipalities received funds from an opioid lawsuit the firm handled.
Their largest individual client win came from a motor vehicle accident. $16.9 million. One crash. One family.
Other seven-figure results
$20 million for medical malpractice. $9.5 million for traumatic brain injury. $2.85 million for a construction site accident. $1.2 million for a pedestrian accident.
Three generations of trial experience
The father was a judge. The sons are lawyers. The mother stars in their TV commercials. You do not stay in business across three generations without winning tough cases.
Every office door carries a sign that says “Nobody from Nowobody.” Their way of staying grounded. They work for regular people, not insurance companies.
What they will not take
Minor fender benders. Small slip and falls. They focus exclusively on catastrophic injuries. Life changing cases only. Brain damage. Spinal cord injuries. Wrongful death.
Where to find them
268 Summer Street, LL, Boston, MA 02210.
3. Rob Levine Law
Largest documented case result: $2 billion+ firmwide
That is the total recovered across all offices and all case types. For Boston specifically, their reported car accident results run smaller but consistent.
Boston car accident results
$100,000 for a client rear ended on Route 44 in Middleborough. The driver suffered a severe concussion and months of headaches.
$18,000 for a client hit in Wareham when another driver failed to stop at an intersection. Neck, back, and shoulder injuries.
$11,500 for a client in Bellingham who got hit on the driver’s side. Whiplash and weeks of physical therapy.
Why they rank third
Their Boston-specific car accident numbers do not reach the seven figure mark that the top two firms have documented. But their overall firmwide recovery of over $2 billion and 50,000 helped clients earned them a spot on this list.
The Heavy Hitter reputation
Rob Levine calls himself THE HEAVY HITTER. All caps. That is his brand. He has been practicing for over 25 years. His team works 24/7 and travels to clients who cannot visit their office.
Free Fee Guarantee
They cover all upfront costs. You pay nothing unless they win. That promise appears in writing on their website.
Where to find them
100 Hano St #16, Boston, MA 02134. Plus 15 other offices across Rhode Island, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and New Hampshire.
Languages
Spanish and Portuguese.
4. DiBella Law Office
Largest documented case result: $2.1 million
A 51-year-old woman crossed the street. A car hit her and dragged her. She suffered multiple fractures and bleeding. The firm secured $2.1 million.
Other results
$135,000 for a client stopped at a full stop when another vehicle struck her on the left side. Neck and back pain. Her airbag did not deploy.
$20,000 for a client rear-ended in the tunnel on Route 93 South. She suffered a detached retina plus neck and shoulder injuries.
Why they rank fourth
Their documented car accident results are solid but smaller than the three firms above. However, their client service and technology set them apart.
The personal connection
Chris DiBella knows car accidents from the passenger seat. His brother was seriously injured in a crash when Chris was a kid. He also got rear ended on Route 93 with his own children in the car.
He says it plainly on his website. “I know what I would want in a law firm. I try to bring that to my clients.”
Technology advantage
They built a mobile app for clients. Take pictures at the scene. Track your expenses. Send documents. Schedule appointments. All from your phone.
Awards
10.0 superb rating on Avvo. SuperLawyer since 2020. Top 100 Civil Plaintiff by the National Trial Lawyers Association.
Where to find them
Boston office. Call (617) 870-0907 for the specific address.
Side by Side: The Numbers That Separate These Four Firms
Here is how these four Boston car accident lawyers stack up against each other by the numbers.
| Firm | Largest Publicized Win | Total Seven Figure Wins (Documented) | Years in Practice | Google Rating | 30 Day Guarantee |
| Michael Kelly Injury Lawyers | $17.6 million | 4+ | 13 | 4.9 (1,000+ reviews) | Yes |
| Sweeney Merrigan | $84.1 million (municipal) / $16.9 million (individual) | 9+ | Three generations | Not publicly available | No |
| Rob Levine Law | $2 billion+ (firmwide) / $100,000 (Boston car accident) | 0 (Boston car accidents) | 25+ | 4.5 | No |
| DiBella Law Office | $2.1 million | 1 | 20+ | Not publicly available | No |
The guarantee column tells you something important. Only one firm puts a money-back promise in writing. That changes how they treat clients from day one.
What Your Settlement Offer Reveals About Your Lawyer
Look at the first number the insurance company puts on the table.
That number is not random. It is calculated based on one thing. Who is representing you.
Insurance adjusters have access to a private database called Verisk. It tracks every settlement and verdict involving every law firm in Massachusetts. They punch in your lawyer’s name. The database spits out a profile. How many cases they have tried. How many they have settled. What juries awarded when they went to court.
That profile determines your first offer.
A lawyer who settles 99 percent of cases gets offered pennies. The adjuster knows they will take anything rather than prepare for trial.
A lawyer who has tried even three cases in the past two years gets offered real money. The adjuster runs the numbers on what a jury might give. Then they offer something close to that amount.
Michael Kelly Injury Lawyers publishes the names of their trial attorneys. John McCarthy. Cole Owen. You can look them up in Massachusetts court records. See which cases they have tried. See what juries gave their clients.
That is the difference between a law firm and a settlement mill. One goes to court. The other cashes checks.
FAQ
Here are seven questions specific to ranking car accident lawyers by case results.
How do I verify that a law firm actually won the case results they claim?
Ask for the court docket number. Every lawsuit filed in Massachusetts gets a unique number starting with the year, followed by a dash and several digits. You can search that number on the Massachusetts Trial Court’s public case access website. If the firm refuses to provide a docket number, assume the case did not happen as described.
What is the difference between a settlement and a verdict when comparing law firms?
A settlement means both sides agreed on a number before trial. A verdict means a jury has decided. Verdicts are harder to get. Insurance companies try harder to avoid a jury. A firm with multiple verdicts on their record will get higher settlement offers for future clients.
Why do some law firms only publish confidential settlements with no dollar amounts?
Confidential settlements include a gag order. The client agrees not to disclose the amount. Some firms use this to hide small results. Other firms use it to hide that a case never actually went to trial. Be suspicious of firms that only show confidential settlements and no public verdicts.
Can a law firm count a premises liability case as a car accident result?
No. A tree falling on someone is not a car accident. A slip and fall in a grocery store is not a car accident. When comparing car accident lawyers, look for results that specifically involve motor vehicle collisions. Mixing in other case types inflates their numbers.
What is a reasonable size for a car accident settlement in Massachusetts?
For minor soft tissue injuries like whiplash with no long-term damage, $5,000 to $15,000 is typical. For herniated discs requiring epidural injections, $25,000 to $75,000. For injuries requiring surgery, $100,000 to $300,000. For permanent disabilities or paralysis, settlements often exceed $1 million.
How many seven-figure car accident settlements should a top Boston firm have?
Most personal injury firms in Boston have zero. A firm with one or two seven-figure car accident results is above average. A firm with five or more is exceptional. Be wary of firms that claim seven-figure results but cannot tell you whether those came from car accidents or other case types.
What happens if the law firm I hire has no trial experience?
The insurance company finds out immediately. Adjusters share information. They know which firms settle and which firms try cases. If your lawyer has no trial record, the adjuster offers less money. They know your lawyer will fold rather than prepare for a trial they have never done before.
The Question Most People Skip
When you call a firm from this list, ask this. “How many car accident cases have you taken to trial in the past three years, and how many of those did you win?”
Listen to the pause before the answer. A firm with real trial experience answers immediately. A firm that settles everything hesitates.
Then ask for the judges’ names. Every trial has a judge assigned. If the firm cannot name the judge, they probably never stepped into a courtroom.
Final Thoughts
You want a Boston car accident attorney with wins you can verify. Not marketing claims. Not radio jingles. Actual dollars that landed in real people’s bank accounts.
Michael Kelly Injury Lawyers secured $17.6 million in a single case and offers a 30-day money-back guarantee. Sweeney Merrigan recovered $16.9 million for one family, plus $84.1 million for Massachusetts municipalities. Rob Levine Law has helped over 50,000 injured clients and recovered more than $2 billion firmwide. DiBella Law Office won $2.1 million for a woman hit and dragged by a car.
Pick two. Call both. Ask them about their last trial. The one who gives you a judge’s name and a courthouse location is the one you hire.
The three-year clock started the day you got hurt. Do not let it run out.